Question

[damelola]

For those of you who will continue to watch House next season:

WHY?

This is not intended as an attack, I swear.  You know I don't pick fights with my friends (random trolls and evil people on the other hand...).  But how are you justifying it to yourselves?  Is it just a case of 'I've started so I have to finish'?  I mean, I know some of y'all would watch snuff for to Hugh Laurie if you had to, and I can't claim I'm any different when it comes to my women.

But I'm genuinely interested to hear what the defence is to the blatant misogyny (and/or casual racism), sharp decline in writing and all-round character assassination (including, most importantly, that of House himself)?  What is it that makes you say that's not how it is or it doesn't matter because.  Like I say, not picking a fight but I feel like I've only seen one side of this so far and I really don't know how the people not speaking up about this are rationalising the showrunners' decisions.

I'm putting this public and enabling anon so you don't have to feel awkward about it all.  Look forward to hearing any and all sides of the arguments outside of the general comm hysteria.

Comments

[spoggly.livejournal.com]

Yeah you're definitely right. Someone, I think in the house_cuddy reaction to LE's quitting, made the point that the show is actually incredibly conservative, despite the way we, and probably the majority of the audience, think of it. No ground-breaking views have ever been really aired, especially in a way that wasn't later undercut by the show's development, and the main attraction was, like you said, House voicing un-socially-acceptable things. The show has always been fundamentally conservative, in holding up the male-dominated medical landscape, and especially later, in undercutting characters who deviated from non-white-male social norms (even, later, House, imo, by going through the whole ~nice guy, quit vicodin, what leg probs~ storyline)

Fiction should always be taken extremely seriously, in my biased opinion, lololol. What is it but our extrapolation of our own societal norms? It's not just description, in the way nonfiction is, it's re-imagining and re-casting, and people (and ourselves) can choose to do that in ways that uphold or subvert mainstream opinions. House has moved towards upholding more than it did, tho.

Me too! A lot of my feminism had fine-tuning through thinking about the things that bothered me in the show, or the things that other fans said about the characters! (and now you will make me, and bammel probs later, blush until my cheeks burst)

Yeah, seriously, if we can't talk about these things at a remove, viewed through a fictional lens, when can we discuss them? It's way easier, imo, to talk about them in reference to a show than in reference to real life.

[ohbilliejean.livejournal.com]

OHHH MAN, SO TRUE ABOUT ITS CONSERVATIVENESS. I was just thinking about that yesterday, actually. I was thinking about the shit hitting the fan with LE's departure, which led to thinking about the attitude of the show, and was like, "Wow, the show is really nothing but extreme conservatism disguised as progressive thinking BECAUSE of the socially unacceptable things House says and does." Except lol, there's nothing progressive about the things House says and does, and there's NOTHING progressive about the attitude of the show as a whole.

A lot of people fall for it, though - a LOT of people seriously think House is progressive thought and opinion and fail to identify the conservativeness throughout. They're like, "OMG IT'S SUCH A REVOLUTIONARY SHOW TO HAVE ON SUCH A CONSERVATIVE NETWORK". Um no, not really. The bullshit House sprouts isn't a great deal different to the bullshit that Glenn Beck sprouts. It's offensive and hateful and infringes on people's equal/human rights. There is NOTHING progressive about that.

It also irks me that the show promotes the idea that being offensive and socially unacceptable and expressing prejudice in the guise of "being confronting" is cool. It just confirms the horrible misconception that freedom of speech means people can say whatever the hell they want, fuck the consequences and fuck whoever gets offended. Fuck, it bugs me so much that people think this attitude is progressive thinking.

I meant, like, fiction shouldn't be taken seriously in that it's not reality and I try not to get too affected by things that happen in fiction. HOWEVER, THAT SAID - everything you said about viewing things through a stage lens (ie, fiction) is spot on and is exactly why I can't *not* take things in fiction seriously. These days, I end up spotting so many horrible, glaring facets of -isms in so many elements of media, fictional and nonfictional, that it makes my head want to explode. Like you said, fiction is an extrapolation of our societal norms, and it's an extrapolation of our social conditioning and social expectations. And so much of that is SO FUCKING HIDEOUS. (Hence, why I *try* not to take things seriously in fiction because I just want some escapism every now and again, but the glaringly hideous issues often end up ruining any chance of escapism for me.)

Omg I've missed you, btw. ♥

[spoggly.livejournal.com]

i want to frame your comment

i've missed you too, and i'm so sorry about so shitty about communication, i've been in such a weird place lately, but i wanna try harder

ilu <3

[damelola.livejournal.com]

You two have made me so glad I made this entry, for srs. <3

[spoggly.livejournal.com]

ahahahha, you started it! i haven't thought critically in a while, not since the finale of COE, and it's so nice to talk about media again, especially with two people whose opinions i hugely respect

[ohbilliejean.livejournal.com]

I'm really glad you've made this entry, too! It's also been ages since I've had a proper, meaty discussion about media, and it's been ages since I've had a proper, meaty discussion about House.

It's actually been awesome being able to have that discussion here, as it's helped me really get off my chest things that have been bugging me so much about the show but haven't had the opportunity to delve into it. (Or, you know, maybe not opportunity so much as courage, especially after how burnt I was from all the shit that went down - I know you know what I mean by that, lol.) So yeah, huge thank you for this post. ♥ ♥ ♥

[ohbilliejean.livejournal.com]

No, I've been really out of touch, too. It's no one's fault - shit happens, life happens, bullshit happens that makes shit in life worse, that's no one's fault and friendship isn't constrained by how much people stay in contact. If it is constrained by that, then it's not a real friendship imo.

I love you, too, and care about you in huge amounts, whether we're in contact or not. I think about you quite a lot, and I think about all of the people on LJ whom are really important to me (dameola, you come under that category, too!) and no amount of lapses in communication will ever change that. ♥

[spoggly.livejournal.com]

You're going to make me cry! I love you so much, as much as someone I'm friends with offline, and I'm so, so fucking glad that that won't change.

[ohbilliejean.livejournal.com]

♥ ♥ ♥